Is Mohamed Salah leaving Liverpool

Should Liverpool Drop Mohamed Salah? Fans and Pundits React to Star’s Dip in Form

Liverpool’s narrow win over Chelsea sparked a heated debate among fans and pundits — and at the center of it all is Mohamed Salah. After a slow start to the season, questions are beginning to surface about whether manager Arne Slot should consider dropping the Egyptian forward from the starting lineup.

During a recent discussion on Sky Sports, former footballer Jamie Carragher and others weighed in on Salah’s current struggles, with most agreeing that talk of benching the club legend is premature.

Carragher defended the winger, saying that Salah’s contribution over the years speaks for itself.

“To talk about dropping one of Liverpool’s greatest ever players is harsh,” he said. “Yes, he hasn’t started great, but he’s earned the right to work through this. His legs haven’t gone — he’ll come good.”

Carragher pointed out that Salah’s dip in form could be linked to the absence of Trent Alexander-Arnold, whose overlapping runs and pinpoint deliveries have long complemented Salah’s attacking style. Without Trent, Liverpool’s right side has looked different, and new combinations — such as Frimpong and Szoboszlai — are still adapting.

“Salah’s used to running in behind,” Carragher explained. “Now he’s getting the ball to feet a lot more. Teams are sitting deeper, and he’s not getting that space to attack. That’s bound to affect his rhythm.”

Fans Divided Over Salah’s Future

Liverpool supporters are split on the issue. One fan, identified as Lak, suggested a more measured approach:

“We should persist with Salah, but if he’s not performing after 60 minutes, then make a change — especially with AFCON coming later this year.”

Another fan, S, argued that Slot should experiment with different players capable of assisting the frontmen, though he acknowledged there’s no clear replacement for Salah’s creativity and experience.

Carragher echoed that sentiment, emphasizing that Salah remains one of Liverpool’s top providers as well as a goal scorer.

“He’s not just a finisher — he creates goals too. The real challenge is finding someone behind him who can feed him the way Trent used to.”

“There’s No One Ready to Replace Him,” Says Fan Abigail Rudkin

Liverpool supporter Abigail Rudkin, speaking on Sky Sports, passionately defended Salah.

“You can’t drop him,” she insisted. “The players around him aren’t playing well either. We don’t have anyone ready to step in at his level.”

Rudkin admitted that while Liverpool strengthened their squad in the summer, no player has yet shown they can match Salah’s influence.

“Isak came on and barely touched the ball against Galatasaray. Gakpo isn’t firing either. We’re really missing Luis Díaz,” she added.

She also highlighted the emotional toll the squad may still be facing after the tragic loss of former teammate Luis Jota.

“People forget these players are human. They’re grieving. You could see Salah crying on the pitch after Bournemouth — that tells you everything.”

Questions Raised Over Liverpool’s Defense

The discussion eventually turned to Liverpool’s backline, where Ibrahima Konaté’s inconsistent displays have raised concerns.

“He’s been rash, making Van Dijk do more work than ever before,” Rudkin said. “It’s frustrating that we didn’t secure Marc Guéhi earlier in the transfer window. That was the signing we needed.”

She believes Liverpool’s failure to bring in defensive reinforcements could prove costly, especially with injuries piling up.

“Joe Gomez can’t be relied on for long stretches because of his injury record. We should have prioritized a defender over signing Isak.”

Looking Ahead

Liverpool’s next challenge after the international break is a high-stakes clash against Manchester United at Anfield — a fixture that could either reignite Salah’s form or intensify scrutiny of his performances.

For now, both pundits and fans seem to agree on one thing: Salah has earned enough respect and credit to be given more time.

“He’s tried, he’s tested, and he’s a proven winner,” Rudkin concluded. “You don’t drop a player like that because of a few quiet games.”

In summary:

While calls for Salah’s benching grow louder among a few frustrated fans, the general consensus remains that Liverpool’s talisman deserves patience. With AFCON on the horizon and the team still adjusting to new dynamics, Slot’s biggest challenge may not be whether to drop Salah — but how to get the best out of him again.